On a recent trip to my parents’ house for Thanksgiving, the second-row seat in my wife’s crossover vehicle broke. My wife and I, along with our two daughters were excited to set out for a long holiday weekend, the first in many years. We took that vehicle with three rows of seating so that when we visited my folks, everyone can fit in one car. While on vacation, we returned from a park, and my father exited the second row, followed by my daughter. The lever was flipped in order to fold the seat forward. When the lever was activated again to fold the seat back into its normal position, I noticed the pop-up indicator on the seat did not retract (the indicator lets you know when the seat is locked into place and safe for passengers). After tinkering with the lever, I discovered that the bottom right side of the seat was not locking completely into the floorboard. I immediately thought about the trip home. Our oldest child gets car sick when she rides in the last row, and our youngest’s car seat occupies the other second row seat. Should I take the risk and let my child ride in the semi-broken seat? After all, three out of the four sides were locked in place, and she would only be in danger if we got into an accident. I just had to make sure we drove extra carefully, and nothing would go wrong. The alternative was dealing with a carsick child- a very unpleasant option.
I share this story because I have seen lab staff having to make similar decisions and potentially compromising their safety. I wonder how many of you reading this blog have one piece of broken equipment in your lab that you continue to use. Maybe it is not all the way broken. Perhaps it is just a centrifuge with a broken latch or lock. It might be a drawer with a missing handle, and the drawer falls off the track when you open it all the way. There are worse scenarios. Right now there is someone working in a lab where the biological safety cabinet sash doesn’t go down all the way, and all the chairs have at least one rip in the leather. I know lab chairs are not cheap, and the company that comes out to fit the BSC costs a pretty penny, but how much do you think do you think it would cost if something catastrophic occurred because these issues were not addressed?
Sometimes we don’t think too much about broken equipment until something bad happens. Why would someone continue to use a broken centrifuge? Would you get on a rollercoaster if it were broken? Would you put your child in a seat that was not fully locked into place? I hope not. I sometimes hear managers say they are looking into fixing the issue, or they are waiting to get a quote, but they are still using the broken equipment. We should never be complacent when it comes to safety. Accidents will happen, fires will occur, and people will get injured while working in the lab. We put safeguards in place to reduce these occurrences, but when we choose to work with broken equipment, we negate all of those efforts. If you notice a piece of broken equipment, you need to take it out of service immediately and let your supervisor or manager know. Managers may not be aware of everything that happens in the department, and they depend upon staff to keep them in the loop when equipment gets damaged. Do not encourage working in an unsafe environment.
We made the executive decision to let our daughter ride in the far back row on the trip home. It was raining and we knew there would be a great deal of traffic. My child’s life was on the line, so of course I chose to do the right and safe thing. Did we have to make a few extra stops? We sure did, about three extra stops were included because she felt nauseated. We were actually about 15 minutes from home before she got sick. I knew it would happen; it was just a matter of time. I didn’t mind this time because it beat the alternative of having something happen to her if we were involved in an accident. In life we have to assume the worst will happen so we can make decisions that protect those we care about. It made the trip a little longer, a little messier, but for safety’s sake we have to be willing to take the long road, work a little harder, and maybe even be inconvenienced at times. Lab life isn’t always easy either, but it is worth the effort to protect those in our department. We should always take on the work to make sure the patients, our coworkers, ourselves, and even our loved ones are always as safe as possible.

-Jason P. Nagy, PhD, MLS(ASCP)CM is a Lab Safety Coordinator for Sentara Healthcare, a hospital system with laboratories throughout Virginia and North Carolina. He is an experienced Technical Specialist with a background in biotechnology, molecular biology, clinical labs, and most recently, a focus in laboratory safety.


